Engine failure leads to overturned Brigadyr L-60 during training flight

Casualties unknown • Sitterdorf Flugplatz (LSZV), TG, CH

A training flight near Sitterdorf ended in an overturned aircraft after a fuel exhaustion caused the engine to fail shortly after takeoff.

What happened

On November 8, 1969, a pilot was conducting a series of solo training flights at the Sitterdorf airfield for the purpose of transitioning to the Brigadyr L-60. During the third solo flight of the session, the aircraft experienced a sudden engine failure at an altitude of approximately 50 meters while the pilot was retracting the landing flaps.

In an attempt to avoid nearby buildings in the village of Sitterdorf, the pilot initiated a right-hand turn and attempted an emergency landing in a nearby meadow. However, the aircraft was unable to clear a slight rise in the terrain. The plane struck the crown of an orchard tree before the right wheel and right wingtip impacted a steep embankment. The force of the impact caused the aircraft to leap over the crest, rotate 180 degrees, and come to rest upside down.

The investigation

The investigation examined the fuel levels and the functionality of the aircraft's monitoring systems. It was determined that the aircraft had been fueled on November 2, 1969, with 67 liters added to the left tank, bringing that side to a total of 100 liters. The right tank had not been replenished and contained only approximately 25 liters.

Investigators checked the fuel sight glasses and found that while the system was functional, the readings could be inaccurate depending on the aircraft's attitude. Upon inspection after the crash, the left tank was found to be nearly empty (0.3 liters remaining), while the right tank contained 23 liters. The fuel selector valve had been set to the left tank.

Findings

  • The primary cause of the accident was fuel exhaustion occurring immediately after takeoff during a critical phase of flight.
  • The pilot had mistakenly believed the left tank was sufficiently full based on visual inspections of the sight glasses during previous flight segments.
  • The emergency landing was unsuccessful due to the low altitude and the unfavorable terrain configuration.
  • The pilot's actions following the engine failure, including attempting to restart the engine and maneuvering to avoid structures, were considered appropriate.

Probable cause

The accident was caused by an engine failure resulting from the depletion of fuel in the active tank, compounded by an unsuccessful emergency landing due to insufficient altitude to clear terrain obstacles.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 1969-11-08 BRM AERO S.R.O. BRISTELL B23-912iS accident near Sitterdorf Flugplatz (LSZV), TG, CH?

A training flight near Sitterdorf ended in an overturned aircraft after a fuel exhaustion caused the engine to fail shortly after takeoff.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 1969-11-08 involved a BRM AERO S.R.O. BRISTELL B23-912iS, registration HB-EZD, at Sitterdorf Flugplatz (LSZV), TG, CH.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The accident was caused by an engine failure resulting from the depletion of fuel in the active tank, compounded by an unsuccessful emergency landing due to insufficient altitude to clear terrain obstacles.

Investigation report by the Swiss Transportation Safety Investigation Board (STSB / SUST). Original record: https://www.sust.admin.ch/inhalte/AV-berichte/556.pdf. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the Swiss Transportation Safety Investigation Board (STSB), Switzerland.

Loading the flight search…