Incident Overview
On 15 June 2000, at approximately 06:35 UTC, an airprox occurred between flight LDA138, a Canadair CL-65 (registration OE-LRE) operated by Lauda Air, and flight DLH3886, a Boeing 737-500 (registration D-ABIW) operated by Lufthansa. The incident took place 8 nautical miles south-southwest of the KLO DVOR/DME, within airspace class C, under the control of Zurich Area Control Centre (ACC) sector Upper 1.
Sequence of Events
LDA138 was en route from Geneva (LSGG) to Vienna (LOWW). At 06:26 UTC, the pilot contacted Zurich Radar ACU1 on frequency 133.050 MHz, reporting climbing to flight level 240. The radar executive (RE) controller cleared LDA138 to climb to FL260 and assigned a routing via BERSU–KUDES–BAMUR. Approximately one minute later, LDA138 was cleared to climb further to FL280. The aircraft was climbing at a rate of about 500 ft/min. The RE asked the pilot if he could increase the climb rate to 1500 ft/min, to which the pilot agreed.
DLH3886 was en route from Düsseldorf (EDDL) to Milan Malpensa (LIMC) at its cruising level FL270, following the UN850 airway via TRA–ODINA.
At 06:30 UTC, the RE instructed: "LDA138, recleared FL260, with at least 1500ft/min." The pilot acknowledged: "Roger, fifteen hundred, down 260, LDA138." Despite this acknowledgment, LDA138 continued to climb toward FL280. After passing FL257, the climb rate reduced back to 500 ft/min.
At 06:34:50, the controller observed LDA138 at FL264 and inquired about its altitude, informing the pilot of another aircraft at FL270 above. LDA138 responded that it was climbing to FL280 and had visual contact with the other aircraft. The controller reiterated the reclearance to FL260, but the pilot maintained that he had been cleared to FL280.
The two aircraft crossed with a horizontal separation of 1.4 nautical miles and a vertical separation of 700 feet. When contacted after the crossing, DLH3886 reported visual contact with LDA138 and stated that it had briefly climbed to FL272 due to a TCAS Resolution Advisory (RA), then descended back to FL270.
Findings
- Both aircraft were in radio contact with Zurich ACC sector U1 on frequency 133.050 MHz.
- At 06:27:34, the RE initially cleared LDA138 to FL280, but at 06:29:58 issued a reclearance to FL260 with a minimum climb rate of 1500 ft/min, which the pilot acknowledged.
- DLH3886 was cruising at FL270.
- Pilots of both aircraft had visual contact with each other.
- DLH3886 experienced a TCAS RA and climbed to FL272.
- The pilot of DLH3886 assessed the incident as "moderate."
- The LDA138 pilot also observed the other aircraft on TCAS.
- After the event, the LDA138 pilot maintained that he had a clearance to FL280.
Assessment
At the time of the incident, sector U1 had routine traffic conditions and moderate traffic density. The RE was aware that LDA138 desired FL290 as a cruising level and that a crossing with DLH3886 would occur south of KLO. Another aircraft was following at FL250, approximately 13 NM behind DLH3886. Initially, the RE cleared LDA138 to FL260, then decided to allocate FL280. However, observing a low climb rate, he requested an increase to at least 1500 ft/min. The intention was for LDA138 to reach FL280 before crossing DLH3886 at FL270. As LDA138 passed about FL200, the RE concluded the conflict could not be resolved as planned and issued a reclearance to FL260 with the climb rate requirement. Despite acknowledging, LDA138 climbed to FL280, then reduced climb rate after FL257. Factors such as visual contact, TCAS monitoring, the climb rate reduction, and DLH3886's brief climb to FL272 allowed a crossing with 1.4 NM horizontal and 700 ft vertical separation.
Cause
The incident was caused by the LDA138 crew not complying with an ATC clearance, resulting in the aircraft climbing above the flight level authorized by the controller.
