Incident Overview
On 30 June 2004, at approximately 16:40 UTC, an airprox (air proximity) incident occurred at Geneva Airport (LSGG) involving Air France flight AFR542D, a Boeing 737-500 registered as F-GJNE, and a state-owned Falcon 50 registered as 9U-BTB, which was operating a technical flight from Geneva to Geneva. The incident took place on runway 23 under visual meteorological conditions (CAVOK, wind 230° at 11 kt, temperature 31°C, QNH 1016 hPa). Airspace class D was in effect, and the aerodrome controller was on duty.
Sequence of Events
Prior to the incident, a Gulfstream V (VP-KBZ) was on final approach to runway 23. At 16:38, AFR542D called the tower, reporting established on the ILS at 11.5 NM from the threshold. The controller asked the pilot to reduce speed to 160 kt to permit a departure. Meanwhile, Swiss flight SWR356E, an Airbus A320 preparing for departure to London-Heathrow, announced ready for immediate departure behind the landing Gulfstream. The controller cleared SWR356E to line up behind the Gulfstream.
At 16:39:49, the controller told the Falcon 50 pilot, who was holding at intersection YANKEE 2, that he was number two for departure. The Falcon pilot acknowledged. The Gulfstream landed and vacated via taxiway CHARLIE, located opposite the Falcon's holding position. Immediately after, the controller cleared SWR356E for a rapid takeoff, alerting the crew of traffic on final.
At 16:41:13, the controller issued a conditional clearance to the Falcon 50: "Neuf Tango Bravo, behind a 737 in short final, line up runway 23 YANKEE behind." The pilot read back: "In short, we line up behind, Bravo Tango Bravo." The Falcon was holding at Y2, and the red stop bars at intersections Y and Z were not illuminated because CAT I procedures were active.
About 30 seconds later, SWR356E (the Airbus) passed the YANKEE intersection during its takeoff roll. After the Airbus passed, the Falcon 50 entered runway 23 at YANKEE and aligned with the centerline. At 16:42:18, with AFR542D at 0.75 NM from the threshold, 1700 ft altitude, and 127 kt, the controller noticed the incursion and ordered AFR542D to go around. The 737 descended to a minimum of 1600 ft before executing the missed approach. The controller then told the Falcon to hold position and remarked: "Yeah, that was behind the 737 that was in short final, not behind the departure." The Falcon was subsequently cleared for takeoff at 16:43:28. AFR542D performed a left-hand downwind approach and landed at 16:57.
Communication
All radio communications between the controller and AFR542D (French) and 9U-BTB (French) were on frequency 118.7 MHz. Communications with VP-KBZ and SWR356E were in English. The controller later stated that due to a busy workload, he did not correct the Falcon pilot's incorrect read-back, as repeating instructions would have caused further delays.
Statements
The pilot of 9U-BTB reported understanding that he was cleared to line up after the second landing aircraft. When he saw a second aircraft (SWR356E) passing his position, he assumed it was the landing traffic and entered the runway, realizing too late that the aircraft was departing. The pilot of AFR542D reported receiving the go-around order at approximately 600–700 ft AGL in excellent weather conditions. An ATIR (Air Traffic Incident Report) was filed by ATC.
