Aircraft impacts ground during circling maneuver at MIC

Casualties unknown • Minneapolis, MN, US

An aircraft impacted the ground short of the runway while executing a circling maneuver during a VOR approach to the airport.

What happened

The aircraft was cleared for a VOR approach to the airport and was performing a circling maneuver to land when it struck the ground before reaching the runway. During the approach, the pilot reported that the aircraft began behaving strangely, describing a wobble or flopping motion in the tail section that did not feel like a stall.

Passengers observed that the aircraft appeared low and experienced a left bank that resulted in a 90-degree roll, pointing the left wing toward the ground. Radar data recorded the aircraft at 1643:03 at an altitude of 1,200 feet MSL with a ground speed of 89 knots. At 1643:04, the pilot noted they were starting to see the ground at 1,300 feet. Following a request for weather, the pilot was informed that visibility was approximately one-half to three-quarters of a mile with a broken ceiling of 600 feet.

At 1644:44, radar data showed the aircraft at 1,000 feet altitude with a ground speed of 82 knots. At 1644:47, the pilot inquired about reversing direction after stating they had the runway in sight. The approach procedure for the VOR or GPS-A approach to MIC requires a minimum descent altitude of 1,360 feet MSL and a minimum visibility of 1 mile for category A, B, and C aircraft.

The investigation

A post-accident examination of the aircraft was performed, and investigators found no anomalies that could be linked to a preexisting condition.

Data from the owner's manual was reviewed regarding performance limits. The manual specifies a minimum multi-engine approach speed of 107 mph indicated airspeed (IAS). With the landing gear down and flaps at 45 degrees, the manual lists stall speeds of 81 mph IAS at 0 degrees of bank, 83 mph IAS at 20 degrees of bank, 92 mph IAS at 40 degrees of bank, and 115 mph IAS at 60 degrees of bank.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2001-03-28 Cessna 414 accident near Minneapolis, MN?

An aircraft impacted the ground short of the runway while executing a circling maneuver during a VOR approach to the airport.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2001-03-28 involved a Cessna 414, registration N8247Q, operated by Air Transport Service Inc, at Minneapolis, MN.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The pilot not maintaining the proper airspeed during the circling approach, the inadvertent stall and the subsequent loss of control. Factors were the pilot's decision to continue the approach in weather conditions below the approach/landing minimums, the continued flight below the minimum descent altitude, the pilot…

Investigation report by the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) historical archive. Original record: https://carol.ntsb.gov/event/20010406X00712. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), United States.

Loading the flight search…