Tow rope fracture leads to unintended release during glider tow in Hokkaido

Casualties unknown • Kitami City, Hokkaido Prefecture, JP

A tow rope snapped during a glider tow near Kitami, Japan, causing the remaining rope to drop to the ground after the glider pilot triggered the release mechanism.

What happened

On July 7, 2019, a towing operation involving two aircraft at Sky-port KITAMI, a temporary airfield in Kitami City, Hokkaido, resulted in a serious incident. An Avions Pierre Robin DR400/180R, registered JA4027, was towing an Alexander Schleicher ASK21 glider, registered JA2288, to an altitude of approximately 3,000 feet.

During the ascent, the aircraft encountered rough airflow due to strong ascending currents. The glider's motion became unstable, causing the tow rope to become significantly slack. As the glider moved closer to the towing aircraft at increased speed, the slack line was suddenly and rapidly pulled taut. This sudden tension caused the tow rope to fracture.

Upon feeling the impact, the pilot of the towing aircraft initiated a descending left turn and radioed a warning regarding the rope break. Simultaneously, the pilot of the glider, who had not yet realized the rope had snapped but feared being pulled into the towing aircraft due to its sudden turn, activated the release lever. This action caused the remaining portion of the rope to drop to the ground, where it was later recovered approximately 1 km south of the release point.

The investigation

The JTSB investigation focused on the mechanical failure of the tow rope and the subsequent actions of the flight crew. Investigators examined the tow rope, which was a 7 mm diameter polyester synthetic fiber rope. They found that the fracture occurred at a knot located within the sleeve of the retractor winch on JA4027.

Technical analysis of the winch mechanism revealed that the sleeve was designed to move backward in a tube and be stopped by a stopper to prevent the rope from being pulled too far from the drum. The investigation also reviewed the flight history and the maintenance of the equipment, noting that the rope was well within its replacement interval.

Probable cause

The tow rope fractured due to an instantaneous, extreme tensile force applied when the slack line was suddenly pulled taut. The remaining rope was subsequently dropped to the ground because the glider pilot, unaware of the break, activated the release mechanism to avoid a collision with the towing aircraft.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2019-07-07 Avions Pierre Robin DR400/180R / Alexander Schleicher ASK21 accident near Kitami City, Hokkaido Prefecture, JP?

A tow rope snapped during a glider tow near Kitami, Japan, causing the remaining rope to drop to the ground after the glider pilot triggered the release mechanism.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2019-07-07 involved a Avions Pierre Robin DR400/180R / Alexander Schleicher ASK21, registration JA4027 / JA2288, operated by Non-Profit Organization Aero Sports KITAMI, at Kitami City, Hokkaido Prefecture, JP.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The tow rope fractured due to an instantaneous, extreme tensile force applied when the slack line was suddenly pulled taut. The remaining rope was subsequently dropped to the ground because the glider pilot, unaware of the break, activated the release mechanism to avoid a collision with the towing aircraft.

Investigation report by the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB). Original record: https://jtsb.mlit.go.jp/eng-air_report/JA4027_JA2288.pdf. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB) - Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism.

Loading the flight search…