Mechanical failure leads to wheels-up landing after nose gear jam

No fatalities • Williamtown Airport, New South Wales

A fatigue crack in a steering link caused the nose landing gear to jam in a partially retracted position, forcing a wheels-up landing.

What happened

During the take-off roll or the subsequent landing gear retraction sequence, a critical failure occurred within the nose landing gear steering system. While the pilot was initially able to steer the aircraft using the rudder pedals during taxi and the start of the take-off roll, the steering link eventually fractured. This failure allowed the nose wheel to rotate significantly to the left, beyond its intended operational limits. This movement caused the nose gear shimmy damper to rotate into a position where it became jammed against a door hinge inside the nose wheel well. Following the failure, the pilot attempted to deploy the landing gear using the established manual extension procedures, but the mechanical obstruction caused by the shimmy damper rendered these efforts unsuccessful. Consequently, the pilot was forced to perform a wheels-up landing.

The investigation

Laboratory examinations of the steering components focused on the steering link to determine the origin of the failure. Investigators identified a fatigue crack on the fracture surfaces of the link, which had originated from a small surface flaw. The size of the pre-existing high-cycle fatigue crack relative to the total cross-section of the link suggested that the final fracture occurred over a relatively brief period of loading cycles. The investigation noted that the material used, a casting alloy, typically possesses lower fracture toughness than wrought alloys, making it more susceptible to brittle fracture. Because the aircraft remained steerable during the initial stages of the take-off roll, investigators concluded that the fracture of the steering link happened either late in the roll or during the retraction of the gear.

Probable cause

A pre-existing fatigue crack in the steering link caused a fracture during the take-off or retraction phase, leading to the nose gear shimmy damper jamming the landing gear mechanism and preventing emergency extension.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2024-05-13 Beech Aircraft Corp B200 accident near Williamtown Airport, New South Wales?

A fatigue crack in a steering link caused the nose landing gear to jam in a partially retracted position, forcing a wheels-up landing.

Were there any fatalities in the 2024-05-13 Beech Aircraft Corp B200 accident?

No fatalities were recorded in this accident.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2024-05-13 involved a Beech Aircraft Corp B200, registration VH-XDV, operated by Eastern Air Link Pty Ltd, at Williamtown Airport, New South Wales.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

A pre-existing fatigue crack in the steering link caused a fracture during the take-off or retraction phase, leading to the nose gear shimmy damper jamming the landing gear mechanism and preventing emergency extension.

Loading the flight search…