6 fatalities

2024-01-23: BAe Jetstream 31 (C-FNAA) — Northwestern Air Lease — Fort Smith, Canada

Fort Smith, CanadaTakeoff (climb)

On January 23, 2024, a BAe Jetstream 31 (registration C-FNAA) operated by Northwestern Air Lease was involved in an aviation accident near Fort Smith, Canada during takeoff. 6 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: During departure, the captain intentionally kept a low pitch attitude and a high airspeed to remove possible snow accumulation on the aircraft. As a result, the aircraft’s departure profile was closer to the ground than it would be on a standard departure. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 1 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781189028Data APIEditorial standards
Aircraft registered C-FNAA
Aircraft registered C-FNAA. Photo: Quintin Soloviev / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

During a night takeoff on Runway 30, an abnormal landing gear indication and a low pitch attitude led to a shallow climb and descent, resulting in a collision with trees. One passenger sustained minor injuries; six others were killed.

Takeoff and Initial Climb

At 0641 local time, during the hours of darkness, the aircraft commenced its takeoff run on Runway 30. Eight seconds after liftoff, at an approximate height of 100 feet above ground level (AGL), the first officer (FO) observed an abnormal landing gear indication and notified the captain. Two seconds later, the FO called for the captain to reduce the speed; the captain acknowledged, and two brief changes in propeller rpm occurred within six seconds.

During the initial climb, the captain maintained a shallow climb angle and attitude. The aircraft's speed increased to approximately 165 knots indicated airspeed (KIAS), and it reached a maximum height of about 140 feet AGL. At that point, the aircraft began a shallow descent.

Descent and Collision

Six seconds after the descent began, the FO observed that the aircraft was losing altitude and called "Descending." One second later, the Terrain Awareness and Warning System (TAWS) produced an aural alert, and simultaneously, the aircraft impacted trees 0.5 nautical miles (NM) past the end of Runway 30. During this impact, the left-wing structure was compromised, resulting in a fireball.

Approximately three seconds after the initial collision, the aircraft impacted additional trees and then terrain 0.6 NM from the end of Runway 30 and 0.1 NM left of the extended runway centerline.

Occupants and Damage

During the final portion of the accident sequence, one passenger was ejected from the aircraft (the seat and safety belt remained in the aircraft) and received minor injuries. All six other occupants were killed, and the airplane was destroyed.

Probable Cause

Officially, the following factors were found to have caused or contributed to this occurrence:

  • During departure, the captain intentionally kept a low pitch attitude and a high airspeed to remove possible snow accumulation on the aircraft. As a result, the aircraft’s departure profile was closer to the ground than it would be on a standard departure.
  • When the captain and first officer attempted to raise the landing gear, the combination of an outside air temperature colder than approximately -20°C and the air load on the landing gear from the increased speed resulted in one of the main landing gear units, likely the left unit, not fully retracting.
  • Following the first officer’s call to reduce airspeed, the captain reduced engine power to reduce the aircraft’s speed and allow the main landing gear to fully retract. As a result of the decreased power, the aircraft entered an inadvertent descent at 140 feet above ground level.
  • The captain and first officer were likely preoccupied with the abnormal main landing gear indication and the aircraft’s airspeed and did not notice the aircraft’s loss of altitude until immediately before impact. As a result, the aircraft impacted trees and terrain 10 seconds after the descent began.