35 fatalities

1999-12-10: BAe ATP (CS-TGM) — SATA Air Açores — São Jorge Island, Portugal

São Jorge Island, PortugalFlight

On December 10, 1999, a BAe ATP (registration CS-TGM) operated by SATA Air Açores was involved in an aviation accident near São Jorge Island, Portugal in flight. 35 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: The crew failed to maintain the necessary altitude during descent, leading to controlled flight into terrain. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A).

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781203891Data APIEditorial standards
Aircraft registered CS-TGM
Aircraft registered CS-TGM. Photo: Pedro Aragão / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A scheduled flight from Ponta Delgada to Horta crashed into the northern hillside of Pico da Esperança, resulting in the loss of all 35 people on board.

What happened

A scheduled service departing from Ponta Delgada Airport at 09:30 local time was traveling toward Horta with a crew of four and 31 passengers. During the flight, the crew encountered weather conditions characterized by heavy rain, strong southwest winds, turbulence, and scattered cumulonimbi due to an active frontal system. To navigate the weather, the crew modified their original flight plan, choosing a path that involved descending over the channel between São Jorge and Pico islands to intercept the Horta VOR/VFL radial at 250 degrees.

While initially cleared to FL100, the crew received clearance to descend to 5,000 feet, provided they maintained visual contact with Pico Island. During this descent, the aircraft entered instrument meteorological conditions (IMC) amidst intense rain and turbulence. Approximately seven minutes after beginning the descent, the aircraft type impacted the northern slope of the 1,067-meter Pico da Esperança on São Jorge Island. The GPWS alarm was reportedly triggered 17 seconds prior to the collision. The impact caused the aircraft to disintegrate, resulting in 35 fatalities.

Findings

The investigation concluded that the accident was a result of controlled flight into terrain because the crew did not maintain the required altitude. Several contributing factors were noted:

  • Errors in the navigation configuration by the crew
  • Inadequate use of the onboard weather radar
  • Failure to monitor radio altimeter settings appropriately
  • The absence of a modern, autonomous navigation system capable of providing high-precision positioning
  • Reduced visibility caused by adverse weather

Probable cause

The crew failed to maintain the necessary altitude during descent, leading to controlled flight into terrain.