What happened
On April 26, 2013, an EADS Socata TBM 700 B was conducting a flight from Kiel-Holtenau to Rotenburg (Wümme) for a scheduled stop to pick up passengers before continuing to Friedrichshafen. The flight initially proceeded under Instrument Flight Rules (IFR). While approximately 5 nautical miles north of the destination, the crew decided to cancel their IFR flight plan and transition to Visual Flight Rules (VFR).
During the final approach, the aircraft began a continuous descent. Radar data indicated that while the aircraft initially maintained a 3-degree glide path, the sink rate increased significantly below 800 feet AMSL, reaching a maximum of approximately 1,400 feet per minute. The aircraft struck the ground approximately 1.24 NM before the threshold of runway 08, about 570 meters to the left of the approach centerline. The impact caused the aircraft to catch fire and resulted in four fatalities. The aircraft was destroyed.
The investigation
The BFU investigation examined radar data, radio communications, and meteorological records. Investigators analyzed the aircraft's flight path and the physical evidence at the crash site, which showed the aircraft had yawed and rolled to the left upon impact. The investigation also reviewed the pilots' flight experience, the weather conditions at the time of the accident, and the crew's pre-flight preparations. No technical malfunctions were identified as contributing factors.
Findings
- The crew elected to proceed with a VFR approach despite knowing that weather conditions at the destination included low cloud ceilings (500 ft) and limited visibility.
- The transition from IFR to VFR was performed while the aircraft was still in Instrument Meteorological Conditions (IMC), meaning the crew could not visually reference the ground.
- The pilot likely intentionally increased the sink rate below 800 feet in an attempt to descend below the cloud base to regain visual contact with the terrain.
- The pilot attempted a go-around at a very low altitude, but the sudden application of engine power caused an uncoordinated yaw and roll to the left due to propeller torque, leading to the wing striking the ground.
- A lack of situational awareness prevented the crew from aborting the descent or the approach before the terrain became an immediate hazard.
- External pressures, including the need to meet a specific arrival slot at the next destination and the presence of waiting passengers, may have influenced the decision-making process.