8 fatalities

1999-09-03: Cessna 404 Titan (G-ILGW) — Edinburgh Air Charter — Glasgow, United Kingdom

Glasgow, United KingdomTakeoff (climb)

On September 3, 1999, a Cessna 404 Titan (registration G-ILGW) operated by Edinburgh Air Charter was involved in an aviation accident near Glasgow, United Kingdom during takeoff. 8 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: Causal factors: left engine catastrophic failure of accessory gear train leading to complete power loss; propeller of failed engine not feathered, making aircraft incapable of climbing on one engine; commander feathered right engine (which was capable),… This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A).

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781204135Data APIEditorial standards

A chartered aircraft carrying nine crew members from Glasgow to Aberdeen crashed shortly after takeoff. The left engine failed; the commander accidentally feathered the right engine, causing total thrust loss. Three survivors were rescued before a post-impact fire.

Sequence of Events

On the day of the accident, the aircraft was chartered to transport an airline crew of nine persons from Glasgow to Aberdeen. The flight crew consisted of two pilots. The aircraft's take-off weight, as determined, was between 8,320 and 8,600 lb, with a maximum permitted take-off weight of 8,400 lb.

Before taxiing from the business aviation apron, the flight crew obtained an ATC clearance for an IFR departure. The aircraft then taxied for take-off from runway 23, which had a take-off run available of 2,658 metres.

According to survivors, the take-off proceeded normally until shortly after becoming airborne, when a thud or bang was heard. External witnesses observed the aircraft at low height, to the left of the extended runway centerline, in a wings level attitude. The aircraft later developed a right bank and a gentle descent. Witnesses reported hearing an engine spluttering and saw at least one propeller rotating slowly.

A brief emergency radio transmission from the commander was received. The aircraft then entered a steep right turn, followed by a dive. A witness saw the wings level just before the aircraft struck the ground on a northerly track.

Aftermath

Three survivors were helped from the wreckage by a nearby farm worker before flames from a severe post-impact fire engulfed the cabin.

Causal Factors

The official investigation identified the following causal factors: the left engine suffered a catastrophic failure of its accessory gear train, leading to a progressive but complete loss of power; the propeller of the failed engine was not feathered, rendering the aircraft incapable of climbing on the power of one engine alone; the commander feathered the propeller of the right-hand engine, which was mechanically capable of producing power, resulting in a total loss of thrust; the commander attempted to return to the departure airfield but lost control during a right turn.

Probable cause

Causal factors: left engine catastrophic failure of accessory gear train leading to complete power loss; propeller of failed engine not feathered, making aircraft incapable of climbing on one engine; commander feathered right engine (which was capable), causing total thrust loss; commander lost control during right turn attempting to return to airfield.