No fatalities

1958-02-13: Convair CV-240 (N8405H) — Western Airlines — Palm Springs, United States of America

Palm Springs, United States of AmericaTakeoff (climb)

On February 13, 1958, a Convair CV-240 (registration N8405H) operated by Western Airlines was involved in an aviation accident near Palm Springs, United States of America during takeoff. No fatalities were reported. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: The failure of a mechanic to secure properly the right wing leading edge section, resulting in its separation in flight; this improper installation was undetected because of inadequate inspection. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 3 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781248641Data APIEditorial standards
Aircraft registered N8405H
Aircraft registered N8405H. Photo: Bill Larkins / CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Flight 19 experienced right wing leading edge separation shortly after takeoff, causing severe control difficulties and buffeting. The crew performed a gear-down emergency landing in a boulder-strewn desert, where the aircraft struck boulders and caught fire. Five passengers were seriously injured; the crew and other passengers sustained minor injuries.

Accident Sequence

At approximately 1342, Flight 19 departed from runway 31. The takeoff appeared normal, and the aircraft climbed to about 500 feet above ground. Shortly thereafter, multiple ground witnesses observed two or more silvery pieces separate from the aircraft, mostly from the area of the right wing. Almost simultaneously, the aircraft pitched nose-down sharply and descended at a steep angle. As it neared the ground, it leveled off considerably but continued descending.

Ground Witness Observations and Emergency Landing

Witnesses reported seeing the aircraft contact the ground, raising a large cloud of dust, and then disappear from view behind higher terrain. Seconds later, large columns of smoke rose from the accident site. The aircraft, which had made a gear-down emergency landing, struck large boulders during its ground roll. A fire occurred that consumed the major portion of the aircraft.

Injuries and Damage

The accident resulted in no fatalities. However, five of the 18 passengers sustained serious injuries, and most others suffered minor injuries. The three crew members received minor or slight injuries.

Probable Cause

According to the official Board findings, the probable cause of the accident was the failure of a mechanic to secure properly the right wing leading edge section, resulting in its separation in flight. The improper installation was undetected due to inadequate inspection. Specific findings included: the right wing leading edge separated during departure; this caused severe control difficulty and buffeting; the crew performed a gear-down emergency landing in boulder-strewn desert about four miles north-northwest of the airport; ground impacts with boulders caused severe damage and breakup; a fire in the left wing destroyed the aircraft; the aircraft (N8405H) had received a No. 3 heavy maintenance check about two hours before the accident; during that check, a mechanic forgot to install retaining screws for the right leading edge; the gap straps were properly installed but failed during departure due to loads beyond their design strength; and the lead mechanic's inadequate inspection failed to detect the omission.