Aircraft crash in Djebel Marra mountains during positioning flight

12 fatalities • Tora Tonga, Sudan • Flight

A positioning flight traveling from Geneva to Mecca crashed into a mountain slope in Sudan, resulting in the deaths of all twelve people on board.

What happened

A positioning flight was en route from Geneva to Mecca, with scheduled stops in Dakar, Niube, and Khartoum. The aircraft was operated with a crew of ten and included two Swiss journalists as passengers. While navigating through Sudanese airspace at night, the aircraft type (not specified) was flying at an altitude of 8,000 feet when it collided with the slope of a mountain within the Djebel Marra range. Following the impact, the wreckage was discovered several hours later. The accident resulted in 12 fatalities, with no survivors among the occupants.

Findings

Investigations into the crash identified several navigational discrepancies that contributed to the disaster. The crew operated under the impression that their ground speed was between 175 and 178 knots, whereas the actual average ground speed was significantly higher, at least 200-205 knots. Additionally, a minor directional deviation of approximately 2 to 3 degrees existed between the intended track and the real flight path.

Over the course of the 2.5-hour flight, these errors accumulated, leading to a positional error of roughly 70 nautical miles to the west and 30 nautical miles to the south. Although an astronomical fix was used for a position report at 1906Z, this report was inaccurate, preventing the crew from realizing they had drifted off course. Consequently, the aircraft struck the mountains four minutes before the crew anticipated reaching the El Fasher beacon, a point where they intended to begin climbing to 12,000 feet. At the time of impact, the crew believed they were still more than 60 nautical miles away from the mountain range.

Probable cause

The accident was caused by accumulated navigational errors involving unobserved ground speed increases and directional deviations that placed the aircraft off course.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 1960-05-15 Douglas DC-4 accident near Tora Tonga, Sudan?

A positioning flight traveling from Geneva to Mecca crashed into a mountain slope in Sudan, resulting in the deaths of all twelve people on board.

Were there any fatalities in the 1960-05-15 Douglas DC-4 accident?

The accident was fatal, resulting in 12 fatalities.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 1960-05-15 involved a Douglas DC-4, registration HB-ILA, operated by Balair - Switzerland, at Tora Tonga, Sudan.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The accident was caused by accumulated navigational errors involving unobserved ground speed increases and directional deviations that placed the aircraft off course.

Loading the flight search…