36 fatalities

1959-01-11: Lockheed L-1049 Super Constellation (D-ALAK) — Lufthansa — Rio de Janeiro-Galeão, Brazil

Rio de Janeiro-Galeão, BrazilLanding (descent or approach)

On January 11, 1959, a Lockheed L-1049 Super Constellation (registration D-ALAK) operated by Lufthansa was involved in an aviation accident near Rio de Janeiro-Galeão, Brazil during landing or approach. 36 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: In spite of an exhaustive investigation it was not possible to determine the actual cause. However, the probable cause was considered to be pilot error in descending below the minimum altitude on final approach. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 4 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781247766Data APIEditorial standards
Aircraft registered D-ALAK
Aircraft registered D-ALAK. Photo: Ken Fielding / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A Super Constellation on flight LH502 from Hamburg to Buenos Aires crashed into Guanabara Bay and then near Flecheiras Beach while approaching Rio de Janeiro, killing 36 people. Three crew members survived.

Background

The aircraft was operating as flight LH502 from Hamburg, Germany to Buenos Aires, Argentina. While approaching Rio de Janeiro, the crew received clearance to descend from 4,200 meters to 3,000 meters approximately 20 minutes before arrival. They were instructed to maintain 3,000 meters until reaching the KX NDB in preparation for an approach and landing on runway 14. After passing KX, the crew was cleared to descend to 900 meters.

Accident Sequence

The flight established contact with Galeão Approach and provided normal position reports. As the aircraft descended over Guanabara Bay, rainy conditions prevailed. During the descent, the nose wheel struck the water. Following this impact, the crew apparently attempted to continue the approach. However, the Constellation subsequently crashed near Flecheiras Beach, short of the Galeão runway. The aircraft was destroyed by the ensuing fire.

Casualties and Survivors

All 29 passengers and seven of the ten crew members were killed in the accident. Three crew members survived.

Investigation

The investigation determined that the crew's duty and flight time exceeded Brazilian regulatory limits, but remained within German limitations. The official probable cause stated that despite an exhaustive investigation, the actual cause could not be determined. However, the probable cause was considered to be pilot error in descending below the minimum altitude on final approach. Aircrew fatigue was considered a contributing factor.