Nighttime instrument approach accident involving multiengine aircraft

3 fatalities • Gainesville, United States of America • Landing (descent or approach)

A multiengine airplane crashed into trees during an instrument approach at night after the pilot attempted to land in visibility conditions below established minimums.

What happened

On a night flight conducted under instrument flight rules, a pilot was transporting two passengers to a distant hospital for an urgent organ transplant surgery. During the flight, the pilot maintained routine communication with air traffic control, flight service stations, and local ground personnel. As the aircraft approached the destination, the pilot noted fluctuating weather conditions characterized by a thin fog layer. While the pilot had identified alternative airports for a potential diversion, the aircraft continued toward the primary destination.

Upon contacting a fixed-based operator at the destination, the pilot was informed that low visibility due to fog prevented the observation of terminal lights. Subsequent communications with a flight service station revealed that automated weather reporting indicated a ceiling of only 100 feet and visibility of 1/4 mile. These conditions were below the published minimums required for the instrument landing system (ILS) approach.

Radar tracking indicated that the multiengine airplane successfully intercepted the localizer and glideslope. The final recorded radar target with altitude data placed the aircraft at 600 feet on the glideslope. However, subsequent radar returns failed to provide altitude information. The aircraft eventually flew below the glideslope and struck 100-foot-tall trees approximately 4,150 feet from the runway 29 threshold. The impact resulted in 3 fatalities.

Findings

Post-accident investigations, including a flight check by the Federal Aviation Administration, confirmed that the ILS equipment was functioning correctly. While a post-impact fire destroyed the cockpit and much of the navigation equipment, an examination of the remaining wreckage showed no evidence of mechanical failure prior to the crash. It is noted that the pilot's decision to continue the approach despite weather conditions being below minimums may have been influenced by the urgent medical necessity of the passenger's organ transplant.

Probable cause

The pilot attempted to execute an instrument approach in weather conditions that were below the published minimum requirements for the approach.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2008-11-07 Partenavia P.68 accident near Gainesville, United States of America?

A multiengine airplane crashed into trees during an instrument approach at night after the pilot attempted to land in visibility conditions below established minimums.

Were there any fatalities in the 2008-11-07 Partenavia P.68 accident?

The accident was fatal, resulting in 3 fatalities.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2008-11-07 involved a Partenavia P.68, registration N681KW, operated by Air Key West, at Gainesville, United States of America.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The pilot attempted to execute an instrument approach in weather conditions that were below the published minimum requirements for the approach.

Loading the flight search…