Emergency medical services flight crashes short of destination due to fuel exhaustion

3 fatalities • Chicago-Executive (Palwaukee), United States of America • Landing (descent or approach)

An aircraft operating an emergency medical services mission crashed into terrain after the pilot reported a loss of engine power caused by fuel exhaustion.

What happened

During an emergency medical services mission, an aircraft was being vectored for an instrument approach when the pilot declared an emergency. The pilot reported that the engine had lost power because the aircraft had run out of fuel. While attempting to reach the destination airport, the plane descended through cloud cover and struck trees and terrain before reaching the runway.

Post-accident investigations found only a negligible amount of fuel remaining in the system. Analysis of previous flight legs and refueling records indicated that the aircraft was burning fuel at a rate significantly higher than the manufacturer's specifications. While a predicted 20-knot tailwind may have been factored into the pilot's plan to reach the airport, the aircraft was operating without the mandatory 45-minute reserve required for instrument flight rules.

Findings

Investigators determined that the pilot failed to recognize and compensate for the high fuel consumption rate during the flight. It is believed that more diligent monitoring of the fuel gauges would have revealed the insufficient fuel levels.

Toxicology results confirmed the presence of marijuana metabolites in the pilot's system, which can impair concentration, vigilance, and the perception of time and distance. Additionally, several operational discrepancies were noted regarding the operator. The pilot had exceeded the maximum allowable duty period of 14 hours, having been on duty for over 15 hours. The company's fuel logs were not being regularly monitored, and the operator had failed to conduct a background check on the pilot, despite being aware of prior driving convictions. Furthermore, a passenger acting as a crew member on previous legs of the mission was not properly documented on the load manifest.

Probable cause

The pilot failed to monitor the aircraft's high fuel consumption rate, leading to engine power loss and fuel exhaustion prior to reaching the destination.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2011-11-28 Piper PA-31-350 Navajo Chieftain accident near Chicago-Executive (Palwaukee), United States of America?

An aircraft operating an emergency medical services mission crashed into terrain after the pilot reported a loss of engine power caused by fuel exhaustion.

Were there any fatalities in the 2011-11-28 Piper PA-31-350 Navajo Chieftain accident?

The accident was fatal, resulting in 3 fatalities.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2011-11-28 involved a Piper PA-31-350 Navajo Chieftain, registration N59773, operated by Trans North Aviation, at Chicago-Executive (Palwaukee), United States of America.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The pilot failed to monitor the aircraft's high fuel consumption rate, leading to engine power loss and fuel exhaustion prior to reaching the destination.

Loading the flight search…