Control restriction leads to helicopter roll at Newtownards Airfield

Casualties unknown • Newtownards Airfield, Northern Ireland, GB

A student pilot's attempt to hover taxi a Robinson R22 Beta resulted in a ground impact after a kneeboard obstructed the cyclic control.

What happened

On 16 August 2005, a Robinson R22 Beta, registration G-CCHZ, was involved in an accident during a private flight at Newtownards Airfield, Northern Ireland. The student pilot had been conducting a navigation exercise, which included a landing at St Angelo before returning to Newtownards.

Upon returning to the airfield, the pilot performed a standard approach parallel to Runway 2 and transitioned into a hover near the 'Heli West' grass area. As the pilot attempted to hover taxi to a parking position on the western side of the airfield, the aircraft began drifting to the right. To counteract this drift, the pilot attempted to move the cyclic control to the left; however, the control handle became caught under a plastic kneeboard and its Velcro attachment strap, which was secured to the pilot's left leg.

In an effort to regain control, the pilot lifted his left foot off the left tail rotor pedal. This action allowed the helicopter to yaw rapidly to the right. During the subsequent attempt to correct the drift using right cyclic input, the right landing skid struck the ground, causing the aircraft to roll onto its right side. The impact caused the main rotor blades to strike the ground and resulted in the engine stopping. The pilot, who sustained minor injuries, was able to exit the aircraft unassisted.

The investigation

The investigation focused on the mechanical interference between the flight controls and the pilot's equipment. It was established that the pilot had performed a full and free control check prior to departure from Newtownards, but this check was conducted while the kneeboard was in place. Crucially, the investigation found that the controls had not made contact with the kneeboard or the map during that specific check. No control restrictions were noted during the previous landing at St Angelo.

Findings

  • The accident was caused by the restriction of the cyclic control movement created by the pilot's kneeboard.
  • The pilot's decision to lift his foot from the left tail rotor pedal allowed a rapid rightward yaw to develop.
  • The physical obstruction prevented the pilot from applying the necessary left cyclic input to counteract the wind-induced drift.

Probable cause

The primary cause was the physical interference of a kneeboard with the cyclic control, which prevented the pilot from correcting a rightward drift, compounded by the loss of anti-torque control when the pilot lifted his foot from the tail rotor pedal.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2005-08-16 Robinson R22 Beta accident near Newtownards Airfield, Northern Ireland, GB?

A student pilot's attempt to hover taxi a Robinson R22 Beta resulted in a ground impact after a kneeboard obstructed the cyclic control.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2005-08-16 involved a Robinson R22 Beta, registration G-CCHZ, at Newtownards Airfield, Northern Ireland, GB.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The primary cause was the physical interference of a kneeboard with the cyclic control, which prevented the pilot from correcting a rightward drift, compounded by the loss of anti-torque control when the pilot lifted his foot from the tail rotor pedal.

Loading the flight search…