Casualties unknown

2018-06-15: (PH-VSX) — Runway excursion, New Piper PA-28-181, PH-VSX, Breda International Airport, 15 June 2018, NL

Runway excursion, New Piper PA-28-181, PH-VSX, Breda International Airport, 15 June 2018, NL

On June 15, 2018, an aircraft (registration PH-VSX) was involved in an aviation accident near Runway excursion, New Piper PA-28-181, PH-VSX, Breda International Airport, 15 June 2018, NL. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: The incidents were caused by incorrect values used in the take-off performance calculations, leading to insufficient engine thrust. This summary draws on records from the Dutch Safety Board (Onderzoeksraad voor Veiligheid).

Sourcesthe Dutch Safety Board (Onderzoeksraad voor Veiligheid)Primary reportUpdated 1785065559Data APIEditorial standards
Aircraft registered PH-VSX
Aircraft registered PH-VSX. Photo: Alf van Beem / CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Two take-off incidents in the third quarter of 2018 involved passenger aircraft with insufficient thrust due to incorrect performance calculations. One occurred at Zakynthos International Airport and the other at Amsterdam Schiphol, which was classified as a serious incident.

Incident at Zakynthos International Airport

During the third quarter of 2018, a passenger aircraft departing from Zakynthos International Airport in Greece experienced a take-off incident. The aircraft only became airborne near the end of the runway. The cause was the use of incorrect values in the take-off performance calculations, which resulted in insufficient engine thrust.

Incident at Amsterdam Airport Schiphol

On 10 June 2018, a Boeing 737-800 encountered a similar problem at Amsterdam Airport Schiphol. The flight crew calculated take-off speeds and required engine power assuming a departure from Runway 09 at Intersection N5. However, the actual take-off position was changed to Intersection N4, which shortened the available take-off distance. The performance calculations were not updated to reflect this change. The aircraft was rotated at the originally calculated speed and left the ground just before the end of the runway. The Dutch Safety Board classified this as a serious incident.

Investigation Context

The Dutch Safety Board has investigated multiple similar occurrences. In March 2018, the Board recommended that the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) begin developing a warning system to alert pilots when thrust is insufficient, stating that such a system could prevent these incidents. EASA responded that the feasibility of such systems has yet to be proven, and the industry continues to search for technical solutions.

Probable cause

The incidents were caused by incorrect values used in the take-off performance calculations, leading to insufficient engine thrust.