ACR X TCASII TA RA EVASIVE ACTION TAKEN DSCNT AND TURN NON ADHERENCE TO ATC CLRNC. POSSIBLE LTSS FROM ACR Y. POSSIBLE SYS ERROR.

Narrative

ACR X ROA TO RIC. WHILE ON A VECTOR TO A VISUAL STRAIGHT IN TO RWY 02 A NEAR MISS OCCURRED WITH ACR Y; LTT. THE REASON NO COLLISION OCCURRED WAS A DIRECT RESULT OF TCASII. RICHMOND APCH CTL HAD ASSIGNED US A HDG OF 150 DEG AT 5000 MSL AND 210 KIAS. WE HAD OUR TCASII ON 10 NM SCOPE AND BELOW RA/TA. I WAS FLYING THE ACFT (FO) ON AUTOPLT. I NOTICED A CONFLICT WITH A TARGET ON THE SCOPE WHICH WAS ABOUT 15-20 DEGS R OF CTR AND SHOWING 800-900 FT ABOVE US IN A DSCNT. AS I MENTIONED IT TO THE CAPT WE WATCHED IT FOR NO MORE THAN A FEW SECONDS IN ORDER TO GET SOME SORT OF IDEA ON ITS TRACK; WE SAW THAT IT WAS DEFINITELY GOING TO BE A CONFLICT SO I TOOK THE ACFT OFF OF AUTOPLT. FROM THIS POINT THINGS HAPPENED VERY QUICKLY. WE WERE CONTINUALLY LOOKING FOR THE TFC. I ROLLED THE ACFT SLIGHTLY TO THE L TO CHANGE THE WINDOW POS. THE SUN WAS FAIRLY LOW ON THE HORIZON AND WE WEREN'T SURE OF THE EXACT CLOCK LOCATION OF THE TFC. IMMEDIATELY AFTER ROLLING L WE RECEIVED A TA WITH THE TARGET NOW AT 6-7 NM AND ONLY 600 FT ABOVE US. THIS WAS ALMOST IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWED BY A RA DSND; DSND COMMAND OF 1200-1500 FPM. JUST AFTER I INITIATED THE DSCNT THE CAPT VISUALLY ACQUIRED THE TFC AT ABOUT 1-1:30 O'CLOCK POS. IT WAS DIRECTLY IN THE SUN FROM MY VIEW POINT AND HIDDEN BY THE WINDOW FRAME OF THE ACFT. EVEN THOUGH I HAD MOVED MY HEAD AND THE ACFT I WAS UNABLE TO SEE THE TFC UNTIL THE ACFT PASSED OVERHEAD. WE DSNDED FROM 5000 FT TO 4400 FT AT WHICH TIME WE RECEIVED A MONITOR VERT SPD. APCH CTL NEVER CALLED THIS TFC OUT TO US. WE TOLD THEM THAT WITHOUT TCASII IT WOULD HAVE BEEN A NMAC. MY OBSERVATIONS FROM THIS EVENT: FIRST I WAS UNCOMFORTABLE SEEING A TFC THREAT AND NOT REALLY BEING ABLE TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT UNTIL TCASII GIVES US AN AVOIDANCE MANEUVER. AS AN EX-FIGHTER PLT I WANT TO MOVE THE ACFT TO MISS THE TFC HORIZ NOT JUST VERT. PROC SAYS WE SHOULDN'T DO THIS. I THINK THIS IS WRONG WE NEED THAT CAPABILITY. WE DIDN'T HAVE TIME TO QUERY APCH CTL ABOUT THE TFC. FROM THE TIME WE RECOGNIZED IT AS A TREAT AND THE RA WAS MADE WAS LESS THAN 15 SECONDS. DURING THIS TIME WE ARE VISUALLY TRYING TO FIND THE TFC. SECOND TCASII NEEDS TO BE INTEGRATED WITH SOME AIR TO AIR RADAR CAPABILITY THAT WILL GIVE US BETTER TARGET AZIMUTH. THIS CASE THE TFC WAS 10-15 OFF FROM WHERE WE ACTUALLY FINALLY SAW IT. I NOTICE TCASII DOES TRAIL THE ACFTS ACTUAL LOCATION. ALSO KNOWING CLOSURE RATE OF TFC WILL ALSO HELP. RADAR WOULD DO THIS. TCASII WORKED IN THIS SITUATION AND PROBABLY SAVED A NMAC.