C172 VFR inbound to LVN described a confusing clearance and/or lack of same when first exiting Class B and then routed back in without a Class B clearance; the reporter alleging ambiguity in the way ATC handled the flight.

2012-02 · NASA ASRS report 996148

Date: 2012-02 · Aircraft: Skyhawk 172/Cutlass 172 · Phase: descent

Anomalies: atc-issue-all-types|airspace-violation-all-types

Synopsis

C172 VFR inbound to LVN described a confusing clearance and/or lack of same when first exiting Class B and then routed back in without a Class B clearance; the reporter alleging ambiguity in the way ATC handled the flight.

Narrative

On a dual instruction VFR cross-country training flight to LVN; I was the CFII monitoring and providing dual instruction to a private pilot conducting cross-country training in preparation for an instrument rating. Upon establishing communication with Minneapolis Approach approximately 5 NM northwest of CFE; we were cleared into the Minneapolis Class B airspace on our direct routing with instructions to maintain VFR at or below 4;500 MSL. As we crossed CFE and continued southeast-bound; the Controller issued us a vector for MSP arrival traffic; instructing us to fly heading 170 and descend to maintain VFR at or below 3;500 MSP. Our compliance with this ATC instruction placed us below the floor of the Class B airspace in the area. Upon continuing on the VFR heading for 5-7 NM; we were instructed to 'resume own navigation direct LVN'. At this point; the aircraft was operating under the floor of the Class B; which was at 4;000 MSL. Upon examining the new direct track to LVN from this point; the student and I both observed that the new direct routing would take us through the 3;000 MSL shelf of the Class B. I thus requested Approach to verify that we were cleared to transition the 3;000 MSL shelf; believing that descending below the Class B automatically voided our Class B clearance. The Controller seemed surprised by my request for this clarification; and responded in a slightly dismissive tone that we were 'cleared into Class B airspace'. We continued without incident; reported LVN in sight; and landed full stop. I believe there exists a certain ambiguity in the manner the Controller handled our altitude assignments while we were under RADAR control within the MSP Class B airspace. We were not notified of leaving the Class B even through we were instructed to descend below the associated shelf floor in our area. I suspect that the Controller's surprise at my request for clarification stemmed from having the assumption that his initial Class B clearance was still valid. If an aircraft is instructed by a Controller to descend below a Class B airspace floor; I believe more clarification should be placed upon informing the pilot(s) if re-entry into the Class B is approved should further ATC instructions place the aircraft in a position to re-enter the airspace.

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.

Loading the flight search…

Frequently asked questions

How do I search flights by aircraft type on FlightFinder?

Pick an aircraft model — Boeing 737, Airbus A320, A380, Boeing 787 Dreamliner and more — enter your origin airport, and FlightFinder shows every route that plane flies from there with live fares.

Which aircraft types can I filter by?

We support Boeing 737/747/757/767/777/787, the full Airbus A220/A319/A320/A321/A330/A340/A350/A380 family, Embraer E170/E175/E190/E195, Bombardier CRJ and Dash 8, and the ATR 42/72 turboprops.

Is FlightFinder free to use?

Search and schedules are free. Pro ($4.99/month, $39/year, or $99 one-time lifetime) unlocks the enriched flight card — on-time stats, CO₂ per passenger, amenities, live gate & weather — plus My Trips with push alerts.

Where does the route data come from?

Live schedules come from Amadeus, AeroDataBox and Travelpayouts. Observed routes (which aircraft actually flew a given city pair) are crowdsourced from adsb.lol ADS-B data under the Open Database License.