11 Mar 2011: BOEING 757-232 (N36638) — Delta — ATLANTA, GA

No fatalitiesATLANTA, GA, United States

BOEING 757-232
Photo: Ryanmac06 at English Wikipedia / Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A Delta Air Lines Boeing 757 departed Atlanta without an active transponder, leading to several instances of loss of lateral separation with other aircraft.

What happened

On March 11, 2011, a Boeing 757-200, operating as Delta Air Lines flight 2086, departed runway 27R at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport (ATL) for La Guardia Airport (LGA). Following takeoff, the flight crew failed to activate the aircraft's transponder and did not contact air traffic control for approximately eight minutes.

During this period, the aircraft N693DL traveled through one controller's airspace and entered another's without any coordination. Because the transponder was inactive, the aircraft's flight data block did not automatically appear on radar displays. Instead, the aircraft was visible only as an enhanced primary target lacking identification or radar altitude information.

While the aircraft was flying without a radar data tag, primary radar data showed that a loss of lateral separation occurred between the Boeing 757 and three other aircraft:

  • A Beechcraft 55 (N36638), with a closest proximity of 1.44 miles.
  • A Pilatus PC-12 (N825MK), with a closest proximity of 0.81 miles.
  • An Atlantic Southeast Airlines CRJ-100, with a closest proximity of 2.36 miles.

There were no injuries reported on any of the flights involved. The incident occurred during daytime visual meteorological conditions (VMC).

The investigation

Investigation into the flight history revealed that the Atlanta Tower controller instructed the aircraft to contact departure control one minute after takeoff. Although the pilot read back the instructions correctly, contact with departure control was not made until roughly 1328 EDT.

At 1324 EDT, the Atlanta TRACON south departure controller noticed an unaccounted-for flight strip and inquired about the status of the flight with the tower. The Traffic Management Coordinator attempted to locate the target on the Traffic Situation Display but could not positively identify the aircraft due to the high number of primary targets in the area.

At 1326 EDT, the crew of N693DL contacted the tower to ask about their assigned altitude. Shortly after, the pilot reported that the transponder had been turned on, at which point the aircraft's radar data block appeared on the controller's display. The departure controller then expedited the aircraft's climb to 14,000 feet to maintain separation and handed the flight off to Atlanta Center.

Probable cause

The failure of air traffic controllers to follow required radar identification procedures, which led to a loss of separation between the departing Boeing 757 and three other aircraft. The pilots' failure to perform adequate preflight checks, resulting in the aircraft departing with an inactive transponder, also contributed to the incident.

Contributing factors

Causes

ATC personnel

Other contributing factors

PilotFlight crew