Mid-air collision near Nantes involving Iberia DC 9 and Spantax Convair 990

Casualties unknown • La Planche, FR

A mid-air collision between an Iberia DC 9 and a Spantax Convair 990 resulted in 68 fatalities and the destruction of both aircraft near Nantes, France.

What happened

On March 5, 1973, at 12:52 UTC, an Iberia DC 9, registration EC-BII, and a Spantax Convair 990 (Coronado), registration EC-BJC, collided in the airspace near Nantes, France. The Iberia flight, operating as IB 504 from Palma to London, was cruising at flight level 290. The Spantax flight, operating as BX 400 from Madrid to London, was also operating at flight level 290.

At the time of the accident, a military replacement air traffic control system, known as the 'Clément Marot' plan, was in effect due to ongoing civil aviation strikes. The Spantax crew had been instructed to delay their arrival at Nantes by approximately eight minutes to maintain separation from the Iberia aircraft. To achieve this delay, the pilot of the EC-BJC initiated a 360-degree right turn. However, due to a lack of clear communication and the aircraft's position, the maneuver led the Convair 990 to cross the path of the DC 9.

The collision caused the DC 9 to disintegrate in flight, resulting in the deaths of all 68 people on board (7 crew and 61 passengers). The Convair 990 sustained severe damage, including the loss of a portion of its left wing near the engine mount. Despite the critical damage, the crew managed to perform an emergency landing at Cognac. All 97 people on board the Spantax aircraft (8 crew and 89 passengers) survived.

Probable cause

The collision was caused by a combination of inadequate air traffic control coordination and pilot error during a period of exceptional-use military air traffic services. Specifically, the assignment of the same flight level to two aircraft with identical arrival times created a conflict that was poorly managed. The Spantax crew's decision to execute an unauthorized 360-degree turn to delay their arrival, coupled with a breakdown in radio communication and the failure of controllers to identify the aircraft on radar, directly led to the mid-air impact.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 1973-03-05 planes Coronado accident near La Planche, FR?

A mid-air collision between an Iberia DC 9 and a Spantax Convair 990 resulted in 68 fatalities and the destruction of both aircraft near Nantes, France.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 1973-03-05 involved a planes Coronado, registration EC-BJC, operated by Spantax, at La Planche, FR.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The collision was caused by a combination of inadequate air traffic control coordination and pilot error during a period of exceptional-use military air traffic services. Specifically, the assignment of the same flight level to two aircraft with identical arrival times created a conflict that was poorly managed. The…

Loading the flight search…