Landing gear retraction error following takeoff workload surge

No fatalities • 19 km east of Cairns Airport, Queensland

A flight crew failed to retract the landing gear after takeoff due to verbal confusion and high workload, leading to an overspeed retraction.

What happened

During the takeoff phase, the aircraft's rotation was slower than required, leading the captain to focus heavily on monitoring the pitch attitude. During this maneuver, the pilot monitoring announced "pitch rate" at a time when a "positive rate" announcement would typically be expected. This verbal similarity, combined with the focus on pitch targets, meant the pilot flying was not prompted to request landing gear retraction. As a result, the landing gear remained extended.

As the flight progressed through the initial climb, the crew encountered several distractions, including abnormal radio altimeter alerts and unexpected flight director indications. When the autopilot was engaged, the aircraft began a right turn toward high terrain, necessitating manual intervention by the captain. This period of high workload and attentional tunneling caused the crew to overlook EICAS indications and increased wind noise that would have otherwise signaled the gear was still down.

Once the workload decreased and the crew noticed the extended gear, the captain attempted to rectify the situation. Driven by perceived urgency and stress, the captain initiated the retraction without confirming the action with the first officer or verifying the airspeed. This resulted in the gear being retracted at a speed 17 kt above the maximum retraction limit.

The investigation

The investigation examined the sequence of cockpit communications and the impact of flight deck workload on crew performance. Investigators analyzed how the semantically similar "pitch rate" and "positive rate" announcements may have caused interference in the crew's working memory. The investigation also looked into the technical anomalies, such as the unexpected flight management system command and the radio altimeter alerts, which contributed to the crew's narrowed focus on lateral tracking rather than configuration monitoring.

Probable cause

The failure to retract the landing gear was caused by a combination of verbal confusion during rotation and high workload during the initial climb, which led to the crew overlooking the gear's extended state. The subsequent overspeed retraction was driven by the captain's reflexive response to the identified misconfiguration under time pressure.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2025-07-24 Embraer-Empresa Brasileira De Aeronautica 190LR accident near 19 km east of Cairns Airport, Queensland?

A flight crew failed to retract the landing gear after takeoff due to verbal confusion and high workload, leading to an overspeed retraction.

Were there any fatalities in the 2025-07-24 Embraer-Empresa Brasileira De Aeronautica 190LR accident?

No fatalities were recorded in this accident.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2025-07-24 involved a Embraer-Empresa Brasileira De Aeronautica 190LR, registration VH-A2T, operated by Alliance Airlines Pty Limited, at 19 km east of Cairns Airport, Queensland.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The failure to retract the landing gear was caused by a combination of verbal confusion during rotation and high workload during the initial climb, which led to the crew overlooking the gear's extended state. The subsequent overspeed retraction was driven by the captain's reflexive response to the identified…

Loading the flight search…