Mid-air collision near Moose Jaw involving Canadair C4-1 and North American T-6

36 fatalities • Moose Jaw, Canada • Flight

A mid-air collision between a four-engine aircraft and a training aircraft resulted in 37 fatalities and one ground casualty near Moose Jaw.

What happened

During an instrument flight rules (IFR) cruise at 6,000 feet, a Canadair C4-1 operated by TCAL collided with a RCAF North American T-6 Harvard, registration 3309. The Harvard was being operated by a single pilot who had recently departed from Moose Jaw Airfield for a local training flight.

Following the impact, both aircraft lost control and descended rapidly toward the ground. The North American T-6 crashed onto a golf course, resulting in the death of the pilot. The Canadair C4-1 struck a residential building in a suburb of Moose Jaw, causing the deaths of all 35 people on board the aircraft and one person inside the house.

Findings

Investigation into the collision identified that both pilots failed to maintain an adequate lookout for other aircraft. While the responsibility to avoid the collision rested with the Harvard due to its position on the right side of the larger aircraft, the T-6 was climbing through altitudes typically occupied by traffic using that airway.

Investigators also noted that a window post on the left side of the Canadair C4-1 may have obstructed the crew's view of the approaching Harvard, though this could not be definitively confirmed.

Probable cause

The collision resulted from both pilots failing to maintain a proper lookout and the T-6 aircraft climbing through established airway altitudes.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 1954-04-08 Canadair C-4 North Star accident near Moose Jaw, Canada?

A mid-air collision between a four-engine aircraft and a training aircraft resulted in 37 fatalities and one ground casualty near Moose Jaw.

Were there any fatalities in the 1954-04-08 Canadair C-4 North Star accident?

The accident was fatal, resulting in 36 fatalities.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 1954-04-08 involved a Canadair C-4 North Star, registration CF-TFW, operated by Trans-Canada Air Lines - TCAL, at Moose Jaw, Canada.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The collision resulted from both pilots failing to maintain a proper lookout and the T-6 aircraft climbing through established airway altitudes.

Loading the flight search…