No fatalities

1972-12-20: Convair 880 (N8807E) — Delta Airlines — Chicago-O'Hare, United States of America

Chicago-O'Hare, United States of AmericaTaxiing

On December 20, 1972, a Convair 880 (registration N8807E) operated by Delta Airlines was involved in an aviation accident near Chicago-O'Hare, United States of America while taxiing. No fatalities were reported. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: The air traffic control system failed to ensure aircraft separation due to ambiguous communications and inadequate monitoring of aircraft positions during restricted visibility. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 1 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781233251Data APIEditorial standards
Aircraft registered N8807E
Aircraft registered N8807E. Photo: RuthAS / CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A collision between a Delta Air Lines Convair 880 and a North Central Airlines Douglas DC-9-31 occurred at Chicago-O'Hare Airport, resulting in multiple fatalities and significant aircraft destruction.

What happened

On the taxiway at Chicago-O'Hare Airport, a collision occurred between two commercial aircraft during ground operations. The first aircraft, a Convair 880 operating as flight DL954 from Tampa, had completed its landing and was instructed by air traffic control to proceed to its gate and cross runway 27L. While the Convair was in the process of crossing, it was struck by a North Central Airlines Douglas DC-9-31, registration N954N, which was preparing for departure toward Duluth via Madison.

The impact occurred when one of the wings of the Douglas DC-9-31 collided with the tail section of the Convair. Following the contact, the Convair came to an immediate halt. The Douglas DC-9-31 lost control and veered off the runway, where a post-crash fire erupted. The fire resulted in the total destruction of the DC-9. The Convair sustained damage that rendered it beyond repair.

The collision resulted in significant casualties across both aircraft. On the Convair 880, there were 10 injuries among the 93 people on board. On the North Central Airlines flight, the accident resulted in 10 fatalities and 35 injuries, with several passengers sustaining serious harm.

Findings

Investigations into the collision identified a breakdown in air traffic control procedures during a period of limited visibility. The primary factor was the failure of the air traffic control system to maintain proper separation between the two aircraft. Specific contributing elements included an ambiguous instruction from the controller, where a critical word was omitted during communication with the Convair crew. Additionally, the controller failed to utilize all available data to track the position of the Convair 880, and the flight crew of the Convair did not seek further clarification regarding the instructions provided.

Probable cause

The air traffic control system failed to ensure aircraft separation due to ambiguous communications and inadequate monitoring of aircraft positions during restricted visibility.