History of Flight
On June 8, 2008, about 2030 central daylight time, a Beech model A36 (Bonanza), registration N7214Y, sustained substantial damage during an in-flight collision with trees, a utility pole, and terrain near Grand Rapids, Minnesota. The pilot was executing a forced landing at the time. The flight was conducted under 14 CFR Part 91 on an instrument flight rules (IFR) flight plan, and visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the accident site. The pilot and two passengers reported no injuries.
The flight departed Falls International Airport (INL), International Falls, Minnesota, about 1945, with an intended destination of Flying Cloud Airport (FCM), Eden Prairie, Minnesota.
The pilot stated that about 40 minutes into the flight, he heard a loud noise followed by a rapid deceleration of the engine, and then a "distinct bang." The windshield was immediately covered with a film of oil, completely obstructing forward visibility. He established a descent at best glide airspeed and declared an emergency with air traffic control. The pilot identified Grand Rapids/Itasca County Airport (GPZ), Grand Rapids, Minnesota, as the nearest suitable airport and altered course accordingly.
During the descent, the engine continued to run rough and smoke entered the cockpit. The pilot realized they did not have enough altitude to reach the runway. He attempted to increase engine power to slow the descent, but the engine seized shortly afterward. He set up for a forced landing to a clearing adjacent to a set of power lines approximately 2 miles east of GPZ. During the landing, the airplane impacted trees and a utility pole, which separated the left tip tank and left aileron from the airframe. The pilot noted that the airplane slid approximately 50 feet after initial ground contact.
Personnel Information
The pilot held a Private Pilot certificate with single and multi-engine airplane ratings and an instrument airplane rating. He was issued a Third-Class Airman Medical certificate on April 28, 2008, with a limitation for corrective lenses.
The pilot reported total flight experience of 1,232 hours, with 162 hours in the same make and model as the accident airplane. He noted 209 hours of instrument flight time. His most recent flight review was completed on March 28, 2008.
Aircraft Information
The accident airplane was a 1984 Beech model A36 (Bonanza), serial number E-2169. It was powered by a 300-horsepower Continental IO-550-B1F reciprocating engine, serial number 296821-R, and a McCauley D3A32C409-C three-blade, controllable pitch propeller assembly, serial number 982568.
Aircraft maintenance records indicated the most recent annual inspection was completed on March 21, 2008, at 3,164.4 hours total airframe time. The recording hour (Hobbs) meter indicated 855 hours at the time of that inspection. The propeller had accumulated 1,226.8 hours total time and 482.3 hours since overhaul.
Maintenance records noted that the propeller spinner bulkhead was replaced on May 23, 2007, in accordance with McCauley Service Letter 2000-5A. McCauley Service Bulletin 227B, Alert Service Bulletin 248, and Service Letter 1991-11A were also complied with at that time. The propeller had accumulated 1,671.4 hours total time and 296.5 hours since overhaul. The airplane recording hour meter indicated 669.2 hours according to the records.
The propeller assembly was overhauled on December 1, 2005, and subsequently re-installed on the accident airplane on December 12, 2005.
Meteorological Information
At 2035, the GPZ Automated Weather Observing System (AWOS) recorded weather conditions as: calm winds; 10 miles visibility; overcast clouds at 6,500 feet above ground level (agl); temperature 15 degrees Celsius; dew point 12 degrees Celsius; altimeter 29.75 inches of mercury.
Wreckage and Impact Information
The airplane came to rest upright near the edge of a tree line running along a set of power lines. The left wing tip fuel tank and left aileron had separated from the airframe when it impacted one of the power line support poles during the landing. Impact marks on the utility pole were about 6 feet above ground level. The components were recovered from the debris path. The remaining flight controls remained attached to the airframe. The landing gear was in the retracted (up) position. The flaps were extended. The recording hour (Hobbs) meter indicated 904.1 when observed at the accident site.
A post-accident inspection revealed that the propeller assembly had separated from the engine propeller flange. The propeller flange appeared intact. The propeller assembly was not recovered. Two propeller bolt fragments and one propeller alignment pin fragment were recovered from the engine cowling. The mating portions of the fragments were not recovered.
A teardown inspection of the engine revealed damage consistent with oil starvation. The crankshaft bearings and bearing journals were discolored and extruded. The oil sump contained remnants of a connecting rod bolt and metal fragments consistent with bearing material. The spark plugs exhibited normal burn signatures. The magnetos produced spark across all leads when tested.
Tests and Research
The recovered propeller bolt fragments were forwarded to the National Transportation Safety Board Materials Laboratory for examination.
Both bolts were fractured through near the center of the bolt at the first or second full thread common to the propeller hub. The nylon insert self-locking nuts were attached to both bolts. The washer faces of both nuts were worn and polished consistent with relative movement against the crankshaft flange. The threads common to the nuts were flattened and damaged consistent with contact to the crankshaft flange holes.
The fracture surfaces exhibited ratchet markings on opposing sides of the bolt stud, indicative of multiple initiation sites. In addition, opposing sets of crack arrest markings were consistent with reverse bending fatigue cracking. The arrest markings were coarsely spaced with some intervening ductile features consistent with high-stress propagation. Fatigue propagation was approximately 80 percent on one bolt and about 20 percent on the second bolt. The remaining portion of the bolt stud cross-sections exhibited features consistent with overstress separation.
The propeller hub alignment pin was fractured near the mid-point at a circumferential groove in the part. The fracture surface exhibited beach marks adjacent to the groove. After the initial radial propagation toward the center of the pin, the beach marks had a coarse appearance consistent with high-stress propagation. The fatigue area comprised approximately 50 percent of the pin cross-section.
The material and plating properties met the manufacturer's drawing specifications.