8 fatalities

1990-12-03: Douglas DC-9 (N3313L) — Northwest Airlines — Detroit-Metropolitan-Wayne County, United States of America

Detroit-Metropolitan-Wayne County, United States of AmericaTaxiing

On December 3, 1990, a Douglas DC-9 (registration N3313L) operated by Northwest Airlines was involved in an aviation accident near Detroit-Metropolitan-Wayne County, United States of America while taxiing. 8 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: Inadequate crew coordination and role reversal among the DC-9 pilots led to an unauthorized runway incursion during low visibility. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 6 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781212388Data APIEditorial standards
Aircraft registered N3313L
Aircraft registered N3313L. Photo: Kev Colbran / CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Two Northwest Airlines aircraft collided on a runway at Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport during heavy fog in December 1990.

What happened

On December 3, 1990, a collision occurred at the intersection of runways 09/27 and 03C/21C at Detroit-Metropolitan-Wayne County Airport, Michigan. The incident involved two Northwest Airlines aircraft: a Boeing 727 (registration N278US) and a DC-9 (registration N3313L).

At approximately 13:45 EST, the Boeing 727 was in its takeoff roll when it struck the DC-9, which had recently taxied onto the active runway. The collision took place amidst dense fog conditions. The impact resulted in the destruction of the DC-9 and significant damage to the Boeing 727. Among the passengers and crew on the DC-9, there were 8 fatalities (seven passengers and one crew member). All 146 passengers and eight crew members aboard the Boeing 727 escaped without injury.

Findings

Investigations identified several contributing factors to the accident. A primary cause was a lack of proper crew coordination, specifically involving a reversal of roles among the pilots of the DC-9, which prevented them from stopping their taxi or notifying ground control regarding their position on the runway.

Additional findings included:

  • Deficiencies in air traffic control services at Detroit tower, such as inadequate visibility monitoring, failure to use progressive taxi instructions during low visibility, and the issuance of confusing taxi instructions.
  • Inadequate supervision of staff levels and deficiencies in airport surface markings, signage, and lighting.
  • A lack of sufficient cockpit resource management training provided by Northwest Airlines to its flight crews.

Furthermore, the failure of the DC-9's internal tailcone release mechanism contributed to the death toll, while improper evacuation procedures by the DC-9 crew increased the severity of injuries.

Probable cause

Inadequate crew coordination and role reversal among the DC-9 pilots led to an unauthorized runway incursion during low visibility.