31 fatalities

1960-06-10: Ilyushin II-14 (CCCP-91571) — Aeroflot - Russian International Airlines — Tkvarcheli, Georgia

Tkvarcheli, GeorgiaFlight

On June 10, 1960, an Ilyushin II-14 (registration CCCP-91571) operated by Aeroflot - Russian International Airlines was involved in an aviation accident near Tkvarcheli, Georgia in flight. 31 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: Navigation error on the part of the crew, causing the aircraft to be off track by 17 km to the north. Contributing factors include: poor flight preparation, poor weather assessment, failure to fix position after departure, absence of radio monitoring,… This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 8 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781246539Data APIEditorial standards

A flight from Sukhumi to Kutaisi deviated 17 km north due to a navigation error, striking trees and crashing on Mount Rech. All 31 on board were killed.

Accident Details

After departing from Sukhumi Airport, the crew proceeded southeast toward Kutaisi at an altitude of 1,200 meters. Poor weather conditions were encountered, with clouds between 600 and 1,000 meters. A navigation error caused the aircraft to deviate 17 kilometers to the north. The aircraft struck trees and crashed in flames on the north slope of Mount Rech (1,436 meters high), located near Tkvarcheli. The wreckage was discovered the following day. The aircraft was completely destroyed by the impact forces and a subsequent post-crash fire. All 31 occupants were killed.

Investigation Findings

The official investigation determined that the accident resulted from a navigation error by the crew, leading to the aircraft being off track by 17 kilometers to the north. Several contributing factors were identified. The crew had been hastily assigned a complex routing the day prior to the accident. Despite the complexity, the company failed to include a navigator or a mechanic in the crew. Poor flight preparation and inadequate weather assessment were noted. The crew did not fix their position after departing Sukhumi. There was an absence of radio monitoring by Sukhumi services. Meteorologists did not inform the pilots about wind components and weather conditions along the route. Shortcomings in ATC services were also cited, as the person responsible for following the aircraft was a trainee who was not authorized to work independently. For a period of 20 minutes (corresponding to a distance of 100 kilometers), the crew received no ATC messages regarding their position or flight path.

Probable Cause

The accident was the consequence of a navigation error on the part of the crew, causing the aircraft to be off track by 17 kilometers to the north.