What happened
The incident involved a Tupolev ANT-9 departing Kazan for a local test flight. The three-engine aircraft carried a total of eleven people: two crew members (one pilot and one mechanic) and nine passengers. Approximately thirteen minutes into the flight, the crew initiated a return to the airport.
While on short final approach at an altitude of roughly 30 to 35 meters, the ANT-9 collided with a Polikarpov U-2 registered CCCP-S227. The Polikarpov was operated by Osoaviakhima (Kazan Aero Club) and was completing its own local flight with two pilots on board. Evidence suggests that during the final approach, the Polikarpov was flying above the ANT-9 and crossed its path before impact.
Following the collision, the Polikarpov crashed into the ground and was destroyed. Both pilots aboard this aircraft sustained serious injuries and passed away two hours later. The Tupolev ANT-9 continued flight for a few seconds before crashing near the runway, where it came to rest broken in two. All eleven occupants of the ANT-9 were slightly injured.
Findings
The official investigation concluded that the accident resulted from poor organizational coordination between the aircraft crews and Kazan Airport authorities. At the time, no proper procedures existed for managing such test flights. The pilot of the Polikarpov failed to identify potential traffic and did not realize the presence of the second aircraft. Conversely, the pilot of the ANT-9 was unable to see the Polikarpov flying above due to the obstruction caused by the upper wings.