59 fatalities

1979-03-17: Tupolev TU-104 (CCCP-42444) — Aeroflot - Russian International Airlines — Moscow-Vnukovo, Russia

Moscow-Vnukovo, RussiaLanding (descent or approach)

On March 17, 1979, a Tupolev TU-104 (registration CCCP-42444) operated by Aeroflot - Russian International Airlines was involved in an aviation accident near Moscow-Vnukovo, Russia during landing or approach. 59 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: It was determined that the fire alarm that activated in the cockpit was false and not related to an engine fire. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 8 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 1781225478Data APIEditorial standards

An aircraft crashed 1,548 meters short of runway 01 at Moscow-Vnukovo Airport after a false fire alarm prompted an emergency return. 58 passengers and a stewardess were killed, 61 others injured. The cause was a combination of crew errors and operational deficiencies.

Incident Description

Five seconds after takeoff from runway 01 at Moscow-Vnukovo Airport, during the initial climb, a fire alarm activated on the cockpit panel, indicating a fire in the left engine. The crew declared an emergency, continued climbing, and was cleared to return to the airport. Several turns were executed before beginning an approach to runway 01 under night and marginal weather conditions. On final approach, the aircraft descended below the minimum descent altitude (MDA) and struck the ground at a speed of 350 km/h, crashing in flames in a snow-covered field adjacent to a wooded area. The crash site was 1,548 meters short of runway 01. The aircraft was destroyed. The accident resulted in 58 passengers and a stewardess being killed, while 61 other occupants sustained injuries.

Investigation Findings

The official investigation determined that the fire alarm was false and unrelated to an actual engine fire. Analysis revealed that the temperature in the left engine compartment rose to 253°C due to a disconnected pipe in the anti-icing system. The accident was attributed to a combination of several erroneous decisions by the flight crew and the following factors:

  • The approach was conducted at night and in icing conditions with a single-engine configuration.
  • The aircraft's total weight was 10,201 kg above the maximum permitted for landing.
  • The approach was performed with a tailwind component.
  • The approach speed was excessive.
  • The crew initiated a premature descent, resulting in ground impact after passing the MDA.
  • There was a lack of crew interaction and coordination.
  • The navigator failed to inform the captain about the decision height set at 120 meters.
  • The approach was conducted with the Ground Proximity Warning System (GPWS) deactivated.
  • The co-pilot failed to monitor instruments properly, contributing to a rightward deviation during the final sequence until the aircraft lost altitude and impacted the ground.

Probable cause

It was determined that the fire alarm that activated in the cockpit was false and not related to an engine fire. Analysis revealed that the temperature of the left engine compartment increased to 253° C due to the disconnection of a pipe coupled to the anti-icing system. The accident was the consequence of the combination of several wrong decisions on part of the flying crew and the following factors: - The approach was completed by night and icing conditions in a single engine configuration, - The total weight of the aircraft was 10,201 kg above the maximum weight allowed for landing, - The approach was completed with a tailwind component, - Excessive approach speed, - Premature descent resulting in a collision with ground after passing MDA, - Lack of crew interaction and coordination, - The navigator failed to inform the captain about the decision height fixed at 120 meters, - The approach was completed with the GPWS deactivated, - The copilot failed to monitor the instruments properly, which contributed to the deviation of the airplane to the right during the last sequence until it lost altitude and impacted the ground.