Left main landing gear collapse following electrical short circuit

Casualties unknown • Lawton, OK, US

A twin-engine transport category airplane experienced a left main landing gear collapse during landing roll after an electrical short caused by a liquid spill led to unsafe gear indications.

What happened

During cruise flight, the flight crew of a twin-engine transport category airplane detected an odor similar to burning or smoldering electrical equipment. Simultaneously, the crew observed that the landing gear control circuit breaker had popped. Upon consulting the company's Quick Reference Handbook (QRH), the crew found that while the manual addressed hydraulic issues, it did not provide guidance for electrical problems affecting landing gear operation.

The flight crew notified the company's maintenance facility, but the technician on duty was unable to assist. To verify the gear configuration, three fly-bys were performed near the tower. Both tower personnel and the flight attendant reported that the landing gear appeared to be down with the gear doors closed. Despite this visual confirmation, the crew elected to land while the gear handle light indicated an 'in-transit' condition and both main landing gear indicators showed an 'unsafe' status.

During the landing roll, the left main landing gear collapsed. There were no fatalities or injuries reported.

The investigation

Post-accident examination determined that the weight-on-wheels relay, situated in the avionics bay directly beneath the captain's station, had shorted. This short circuit caused the landing gear control circuit breaker to trip. Investigators traced the electrical short to a soda can that had been spilled on the flight deck during a previous flight.

The investigation further revealed that the cockpit floor lacked carpeting or sealing, which allowed fluids and moisture to seep into the electrical compartment located under the floor.

Probable cause

An electrical short in the weight-on-wheels relay, caused by a soda can spill on the flight deck, led to the landing gear control circuit breaker popping and subsequent gear collapse during landing.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 1998-02-22 Saab-scania AB (saab) 340B accident near Lawton, OK?

A twin-engine transport category airplane experienced a left main landing gear collapse during landing roll after an electrical short caused by a liquid spill led to unsafe gear indications.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 1998-02-22 involved a Saab-scania AB (saab) 340B, registration N396AE, operated by Simmons Airlines, at Lawton, OK.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

An electrical short in the weight-on-wheels relay, caused by a soda can spill on the flight deck, led to the landing gear control circuit breaker popping and subsequent gear collapse during landing.

Investigation report by the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) historical archive. Original record: https://carol.ntsb.gov/event/20001211X09539. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), United States.

Loading the flight search…