2 fatalities

2023-02-17: Robinson R44 (RA-04340) — ИП Каранова Мария Игоревна — РФ, Сахалинская область, городской округ Южно-Сахалинск, на удалении около 17.8 км севернее КТ посадочной площадки Оленья горка

РФ, Сахалинская область, городской округ Южно-Сахалинск, на удалении около 17.8 км севернее КТ посадочной площадки Оленья горка

On February 17, 2023, a Robinson R44 (registration RA-04340) operated by ИП Каранова Мария Игоревна was involved in an aviation accident near РФ, Сахалинская область, городской округ Южно-Сахалинск, на удалении около 17.8 км севернее КТ посадочной площадки Оленья горка. 2 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: The commander's decision to take off was unjustified as the forecast weather conditions did not meet the VFR minima and the requirements of the operator's flight manual. This summary draws on records from the Interstate Aviation Committee (MAK); 8 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Interstate Aviation Committee (MAK)Primary reportUpdated 1779639930Data APIEditorial standards

Investigation reveals that a helicopter commander made an unjustified takeoff decision despite weather forecasts at the destination not meeting VFR minima and operator's flight manual requirements for mountain flights.

Background

According to the official accident investigation report, the incident involved a helicopter operating under the flight manual (RPP) of IP Karanova M.I. The flight was intended for aerial survey work. The commander was required to make the takeoff decision after briefing with the customer and assessing actual weather and lighting conditions.

Weather Conditions

The weather forecast for the Khabarovsk FIR (Area 16, where the accident occurred) predicted a cloud base of 900 meters above sea level and mountain obscuration. The maximum terrain elevation within a 2-kilometer strip along the planned route from Olenya Gorka to Peak Chekhov was 1050 meters. According to section 7.1 of the operator's RPP, for daytime aerial surveys over mountains up to 2000 meters, the weather minima require a cloud base no lower than 400 meters above ground and visibility of at least 2000 meters. The forecast conditions at the destination (Peak Chekhov) did not meet these VFR minima or the RPP requirements.

Decision

The report states that it was not possible to determine whether the commander had information about the actual and forecast weather at the time of the takeoff decision. Nonetheless, the commander's decision to take off was considered unjustified. After preparing the helicopter with the assistance of a maintenance technician and maneuvering it out of the hangar, two passengers arrived at Olenya Gorka. The commander boarded them, and at 03:59 requested clearance from the Sakhalin ATC tower to start the engine.

Conclusion

The investigation concluded that the takeoff decision was made without proper justification given the adverse weather forecast.

Probable cause

The commander's decision to take off was unjustified as the forecast weather conditions did not meet the VFR minima and the requirements of the operator's flight manual.