Casualties unknown

2013-08-05: Boeing 737-900 (HL7599) — Korean Air Lines Co., Ltd. — On the runway 10 in Niigata Airport, JP

On the runway 10 in Niigata Airport, JP

On August 5, 2013, a Boeing 737-900 (registration HL7599) operated by Korean Air Lines Co., Ltd. was involved in an aviation accident near On the runway 10 in Niigata Airport, JP. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: The probable cause is that the captain did not reduce the aircraft to a sufficiently low speed while approaching the runway threshold lights, which he misinterpreted as stop bar lights for intersecting runway 04/22. This summary draws on records from the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB); 11 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB)Primary reportUpdated 1785096185Data APIEditorial standards
Aircraft registered HL7599
Aircraft registered HL7599. Photo: Alec Wilson from Khon Kaen, Thailand / CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

On August 5, 2013, a Korean Air Boeing 737-900 overran runway 10 at Niigata Airport after landing, coming to rest with the nose gear in the grass. None of the 115 occupants were injured.

Introduction

On August 5, 2013, at 19:42 Japan Standard Time, a Boeing 737-900 operated by Korean Air as scheduled flight KAL 763 landed on runway 10 at Niigata Airport. The aircraft was unable to stop within the runway and came to rest with its nose gear in the grass area at the easterly end of the runway. The aircraft carried a total of 115 persons: a captain, eight crewmembers, and 106 passengers. No injuries occurred.

Flight History

The aircraft departed Incheon International Airport at 18:09 under instrument flight rules. The flight plan estimated a total elapsed time of 1 hour 46 minutes to Niigata Airport, with Narita International Airport as the alternate. The captain served as pilot flying (PF) in the left seat, and the first officer (F/O) served as pilot monitoring (PM) in the right seat.

At 19:37:36, the aircraft made initial contact with Niigata Tower and was instructed to continue the approach for runway 10. At 19:38:27, the tower issued a landing clearance for runway 10 and reported wind from 040° at 4 kt. The autopilot was disengaged at about 1,000 ft altitude with an airspeed of 151 kt, followed by the auto throttle disconnection. The aircraft passed the runway 10 threshold at 150 kt and touched down at 143 kt with a vertical acceleration of 1.34 G. Speed brakes deployed automatically, and thrust reversers were used. At 19:41:06, the captain stated, "We are going to roll to the end of runway." The F/O responded affirmatively. The captain called for reverse idle at about 80 kt, and thrust levers were retarded. The speed brake lever stowed at 73 kt. The aircraft overran the runway.

Probable Causes

The Japan Transport Safety Board determined that the serious incident likely occurred because the captain did not reduce the aircraft's speed sufficiently while approaching the runway threshold lights, which he misunderstood as the stop bar lights for intersecting runway 04/22. When he realized there was no runway beyond those lights, the aircraft could not stop within the runway. Contributing factors included the crew's misinterpretation of an ATC instruction to "cross runway 04/22" as a clearance to cross during landing roll rather than a taxi instruction after vacating, and the captain disarming the autobrakes at about 70 kt, followed by inadequate manual braking. Additionally, the crew lacked familiarity with Niigata Airport's intersecting runway, and limited visual cues at night hindered their speed judgment at low speeds.

Investigation report by the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB). Original record: https://jtsb.mlit.go.jp/eng-air_report/HL7599.pdf. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB) - Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism.