4 fatalities

Korean Air Flight 8509 Crash at Stansted (HL7451)

Stansted, United KingdomTakeoff (climb)

On December 22, 1999, a Boeing 747-200 (registration HL7451) operated by Korean Air Cargo was involved in an aviation accident near Stansted, United Kingdom during takeoff. 4 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: The pilots did not respond appropriately to comparator warnings during the climb after takeoff from Stansted despite prompts from the flight engineer. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 8 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 2026-06-11Data APIEditorial standards
Boeing 747-200
Photo: Tosaka / CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A Boeing 747 HL-7451 crashed after takeoff from Stansted following an ADI fault. The aircraft entered a steep left bank and descended at high speed after comparator warnings.

Arrival and Maintenance at Stansted Boeing 747 HL-7451 arrived at Stansted at 15:05 from Tashkent. The flight engineer recorded in the Technical Log that the captain's Attitude Director Indicator (ADI) was unreliable in roll and verbally informed the operator's ground engineer. During turnover, repair work was performed on the ADI. Cargo was offloaded and reloaded for the flight to Milan-Malpensa, with a takeoff weight of 548,352 lb including 68,300 lb of fuel. A new crew boarded the aircraft. ## Departure and Initial Climb After a one-hour delay due to ATC not receiving the flight plan, Flight 8509 was cleared to depart Stand Alpha 6 and taxi to the runway 23 holding point at 18:25. At 18:36, KAL 8509 was cleared for takeoff with a reported surface wind of 190 degrees at 18 knots. The Dover 6R Standard Instrument Departure required a climb ahead to 1.5 miles DME, followed by a left turn onto the 158 inbound radial to the Detling VOR. ## Comparator Warnings and Loss of Control While climbing through 900 feet, the ADI 'Comparator' buzzer sounded three times. Shortly after, it sounded two more times as the captain expressed concerns about his DME indication. At 1,400 feet, ATC instructed the crew to contact London Control. As the captain initiated the procedure turn to the left, the comparator warning sounded approximately nine more times. The aircraft reached a maximum altitude of 2,532 feet above mean sea level before banking progressively to the left and entering a descent. It struck the ground with an approximate 40-degree nose-down pitch and 90-degree left bank at a speed estimated between 250 and 300 knots.

Probable cause

The pilots did not respond appropriately to comparator warnings during the climb after takeoff from Stansted despite prompts from the flight engineer. The commander, as the handling pilot, maintained a left roll control input, rolling the aircraft to approximately 90 degrees of left bank, with no control input to correct the pitch attitude throughout the turn. The first officer either did not monitor the aircraft attitude during the climbing turn or, having done so, did not alert the commander to the extreme unsafe attitude that developed. Maintenance activity at Stansted was misdirected despite the fault having been correctly reported using the Fault Reporting Manual, resulting in the aircraft being presented for service with the same fault experienced on the previous sector; the No 1 INU roll signal driving the captain's ADI was erroneous. The agreement for local engineering support of the operator's engineering personnel was unclear on the division of responsibility, resulting in erroneous defect identification and misdirected maintenance action.