Engine Torque Exceedance During Go-Around in Saab 340A

Casualties unknown • Warszawa (EPWA), PL

A Saab 340A experienced engine torque limits exceeding permissible values during a missed approach at Warsaw Chopin Airport due to failure to activate the CTOT system.

What happened

On January 17, 2020, a Saab 340A, registration SP-KPV, was performing a flight from UKKK to EPWA (Warsaw Chopin Airport). During the approach to landing at EPWA, the aircraft was found to be too high relative to the glidepath after passing the Gosit waypoint. Consequently, the crew decided to execute a go-around.

Following the incident, Flight Data Monitor (FDM) analysis revealed that during the initial climb, the propeller shaft torque (TRQ) exceeded the maximum allowable limit of 108% on both engines. The left engine reached 127% TRQ and the right engine reached 119% TRQ. This condition persisted for 30 seconds, significantly exceeding the maximum permissible transient period of 12 seconds. Additionally, at propeller speeds between 900 and 1396 RPM, the torque exceeded the limit of 644 Nm (475 lbf ft), reaching 122% TRQ.

The investigation

The investigation focused on the technical parameters recorded by the FDM and the crew's operational procedures. It was established that the crew failed to activate the Constant Torque on Take-Off (CTOT) system during the go-around procedure. This system is designed to protect the engines by preventing the TRQ from exceeding the crew-set limit of 108%.

Due to the exceedance, the aircraft was withdrawn from service pending engine replacements. The removed engines were scheduled for inspection according to the EMM CT7 maintenance documentation. Furthermore, a non-destructive testing (NDT) inspection of the left propeller hub was required due to the high torque levels recorded.

Probable cause

The primary cause of the torque exceedance was the crew's failure to activate the CTOT system during the go-around maneuver. Contributing factors included a poorly planned descent that resulted in the aircraft being above the glidepath, a lack of effective communication and cooperation between the captain and the first officer due to personal conflict, and a distraction involving the first officer's ongoing line check.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2020-01-17 SAAB - 340A accident near Warszawa (EPWA), PL?

A Saab 340A experienced engine torque limits exceeding permissible values during a missed approach at Warsaw Chopin Airport due to failure to activate the CTOT system.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2020-01-17 involved a SAAB - 340A, registration SP-KPV, operated by Pilot samolotowy liniowy ATPL, at Warszawa (EPWA), PL.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The primary cause of the torque exceedance was the crew's failure to activate the CTOT system during the go-around maneuver. Contributing factors included a poorly planned descent that resulted in the aircraft being above the glidepath, a lack of effective communication and cooperation between the captain and the…

Investigation report by the Polish State Commission on Aircraft Accidents Investigation (PKBWL). Original record: https://pkbwl.gov.pl/raporty/2020-0844/. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the Panstwowa Komisja Badania Wypadkow Lotniczych (PKBWL), Poland.

Loading the flight search…